Movie Review: 5 Weddings

Movie Review: 5 Weddings

5 Weddings

5 Weddings

Times Of India's Rating2.0/5
Avg. Users' Rating5/5
Rate Movie
CAST:Nargis Fakhri, Rajkummar Rao, Bo Derek, Candy Clark, Anneliese van der Pol
DIRECTION:Namrata Singh Gujral
GENRE:Romance
DURATION:2 hours 20 minutes
Critic's Rating: 2.0/5
To revive the ratings of her fashion magazine and with the added incentive of becoming its new editor, US based fashion writer Shania Dhaliwal (Nargis Fakhri) lands an assignment covering Indian weddings -- or make that Punjabi weddings -- in India. The catch is that after getting estranged from her Indian father at the age of six and coming to the US with her American mother (Bo Derek), she sort of hates her native country. However, her editor persuades her to take the assignment and her mother gives her a package addressed to her former husband, so the business trip gets a personal flavour as well. Upon coming to India, she gets saddled with an escort in the form of a cop Harbhajan Singh (Rajkummar Rao) and a funny driver, Donald (Ravi Aneja). She attends five different ceremonies at five weddings and finds the hijras (eunuchs) everywhere she goes. She’s fascinated by the transgenders and wants to write an article on them as well, which isn’t liked by the authorities, who want to put a stop to it. She also finds herself falling in love with Harbhajan. How life resolves all her problems forms the crux of the story...

NRIs getting in touch with their roots and finding themselves in the process was the staple of the ’90s and hence the film looks twenty years too late. Why is an escort assigned to a journalist? She isn’t going on a war zone but is attending weddings. The reason for her estrangement with her father isn’t explained at all. Why does she hesitate to meet him? Her assignment was covering weddings so why is our heroine so interested in transgenders? A google search would have told her what hijras are. In any which case, knowing what they are or writing about them poses no danger to India’s culture so why are the powers-to-be so secretive about them. 

The film looks like a bright idea on paper but is a rather disjointed effort on execution. We neither get the madness of the Indian weddings nor does the heroine get an emotional closure vis-a-vis her father. It’s a wishy-washy affair which looks like an amateur video made on Punjabi weddings at best. The humour is derived mostly through poking fun at the Indian accent when it comes to speaking English and that’s akin to reducing India to a land of snake-charmers and magicians. Nargis Fakhri looks apt for her role and makes the most of the opportunity as the confused NRI trying to reconcile herself to the idea of a new India. Rajkummar Rao as a Punjabi cop is certainly a new deal and much could have been made out of it. His under-utilisation is clearly a case of opportunity lost. The actor gamely pulls on despite knowing he’s batting for a lost cause. The leads do share a certain camaraderie and it would be interesting to see Nargis and Rajkummar cast together in a better film...

Movie Review: Dassehra

Movie Review: Dassehra

Dassehra

Dassehra

Times Of India's Rating2.0/5
Avg. Users' Rating3/5
Rate Movie
CAST:Neil Nitin Mukesh, Tina Desai, Manish Vatsalya, Govind Namdev, Murli Sharma, Sharat Saxena
DIRECTION:Manish Vatsalya
GENRE:Action
DURATION:2 hours 20 minutes
Critic's Rating: 2.0/5
Aditi (Tina Desai) is Rudra's (Neil Nitin Mukesh) wife and his senior in the police force. While she's a stickler for rules, he believes in bending them and as a result is always being shunted from one posting to another. Aditi and he are both assigned to solve an alleged case of multiple suicide involving four girls. They discover that the corrupt CM of the state, Yadav (Govind Namdev) and his chief goon Shankar (Manish Vatsalya) have a hand in the gruesome affair. Political pressure is applied on the husband and wife team to silence their findings and when that doesn't work, the politician resorts to violence. Now Rudra has to take matters in his hands and break the rules in order to garner justice...

The film's hallmarks are over the top violence, the kind that we see in South potboilers. The hero kicks a jeep and it goes forward ten feet, knocking people down, he grabs a goon and literally Hulk smashes him into the mud, he punches someone and the man goes flying -- you get the picture. There is a certain type of physique or a certain type of screen image associated with such violence. It's kind of silly when anyone does it, even Ajay Devgn or Akshay Kumar but it looks sillier when Neil Nitin Mukesh -- whom we associate as being more of a chocolate hero -- goes about bashing up the baddies like Prabhas. The film belongs to the '80s, with its stereotypical villains and netas and a weak police force which is unable to do anything. In the day and age of social media outrage, a CM orders the police top official to tie up his shoes and clean them in public. It's caught on camera and the news is all over the place and yet nothing happens to the CM's political career nor is there a protest by the IPS board. 

It's not just an actioner but a murder mystery as well but we don't get to see a forensic team at work. Goons come and kill four girls in a college hostel and yet there are no witnesses, no CC camera footage. The clues that the police does get are more by chance than by actual detective work. We have come to expect some level of precision when it comes to writing nowadays but the writers of the present film didn't believe in providing details. 

We want to know why Neil Nitin Mukesh, who is a fine enough actor, signed this film. Does he want to become an action hero now? He tries hard to own that space and in a well-structured film we wouldn't have minded him as a cop but in its present form the film doesn’t do anything for him. Tina Desai gamely gives her hundred percent as the female officer who is forced to serve a lecherous CM but her efforts too are stymied by the weak writing. Govind Namdev hams his way as a thug politician. This is the nth such role he has essayed and the actor clearly needs to move out of the zone. 

Angry cop movies need an emotional core. They at least need a coherent plot. And need to be products of their time. Director Manish Vatsalya, who has also acted in the film as Shankar, Govind Namdev’s chief henchman, needs to go back to the drawing board before attempting something like this ever again...

hello

hello